Wow, the iPage idea has generated a lot of discussion! Less than a year ago I distributed some printouts from the eInk website here at Thomas Nelson and had a hard time finding anyone who was interested. Now it seems to be an idea whose time has come. I have had many discussions and read several blogs on the topic recently. Here is my reply to several questions about the iPage idea.
Durability: I have dropped and otherwise abused my Samsung phone many times and it is still working. Quality technology can be built. Also with technology like eInk's flexible display instead of glass and hard plastics, the iPage will be incredible durable.
Keyboard Vs. Stylus: USB technology makes it simple to plug in other input and storage devices in addition to connecting to the internet. Also there is a new device that can project a keyboard onto any flat surface make portable keyboards even more portable.
Smell and feel: This can be bound into a traditional book binding complete with the smell of fresh ink.
Price: This is a cool idea, but you have to remember that there are two very different types of product that can come out of this technology. One is a full feature PDA with all the bells and whistles the other is a simple book, read only, 2 buttons to flip pages, limited storage, black and white, small trim, cannot brake it, and really cheap. It is the low end that will for some people replace books. The other can go after the laptop and PDA market. If you can keep these ideas separate I think you will start to see how very possible this is.
Browse-ability: A big part of what sells a book is a quick look at the cover, author-bio, and a quick scan through the pages. You should never judge a book by its cover, but most people do. This same method of scanning can be replicated with electronic media also. Amazon does not seem to be having difficultly selling books. Bookstores could even feature wall-size displays of book covers that you could touch to display the contents.
Protecting current investment: Wouldn't be neat if a recycling company could be authorized to trade printed books for electronic copies? Or maybe this could be done by some other organizations that are interested in preserving books in printed form, or both. You could scan them the first time if they are not already in electronic form then trade, possibly for a minimal fee.
Intellectual property rights without annoying or offending the customer: see my
iTales proposal.
Here are a few of the blogs that inspired this post:
http://markhorne.blogspot.com/2005/12/ipage-anyone.html http://deepkeel.com/2005/12/12/182 http://george.sudarkoff.com/2005/12/electronic_book.html http://www.iampowered.com/archives/2005/12/22/the_future_of_traditional_book_1.php http://nickciske.com/blog/2006/01/31/why-ebooks-are-complimentary-not-revolutionary/